ORIGINAL SUIT NO.414 OF 2014

Case between Krishnan.K et al vs State of Kerala et al regarding permanent prohibitory injunction

Court

Court of the Munsiff of Tirur

Judge

Smt. Vincy.T.V.

Order Date

2017-06-27

Duration

2 years 4 months 6 days

Find Similar Cases

Case Summary

Plaintiffs Krishnan.K et al filed a suit seeking permanent prohibitory injunction against the State of Kerala and others, but the court ruled that the suit should be presented before the Land Revenue Commissioner in Thiruvananthapuram due to lack of jurisdiction.

Judgment Outcome

Defendant Won

Interim Order

The court ruled that due to an express bar under the provisions of the Kerala Land Conservancy Act, the civil Court has no jurisdiction to entertain the suit and hence returned it for filing before the proper forum.

Judgment Favored

Defendant

Relief Granted

Returning the plaint for presentation before the Land Revenue Commissioner in Thiruvananthapuram

Case Type

Civil Suit - Permanent Prohibitory Injunction

Final Judgment

Key Reasoning:
Reason not clearly mentioned

Judgment Evidence:

Suit for permanent prohibitory Injunction. IA 1365/2017 allowed. Plaint is returned under order VII Rule 10 for presentation before proper forum Land Revenue commissioner, Thiruvananthapuram.

Parties Involved

Plaintiffs

Krishnan.K (72 years) Karuvayiparambil House, Kalpakancheri amsom & Post. Kallingal paramba, Pin: 676 551 Sanal Kumar. K.P (32 years) Karuvayiparambil House, Kalpakancheri amsom & Post. Kallingal paramba, Pin: 676 551 Karthiayani, K.P (52 years) Kalathumkandi House, Thenhipalam amsom & Post. Pin: 673 636 Kalliani.K.P (48 years) Karuvanthodi House, Ponmala amsom & Post. Pin: 676 503 Padmavathy, K.P (46 years) Kizhakkekkara House, Kolakkad Post, Pin: 679 571 Devaki.K.P (42 years) Kollathedath House, Iringavoor Post and amsom, Pin: 676 303 Shailaja.K.P (38 years) Padikkal House, Thenhipalam amsom & Post, Pin: 673 636 Subhadra, K.P (49 years) Komeri House, Munduparamba amsom & Post, Pin: 676 509 Sarojini. K.P (52 years) Vellilath Hosue, Ezhur Post, Pin: 676 101

Defendants

State of Kerala (Age not specified years) Civil Station, Malappuram, & Post, Pin: 676 509 Additional Tahasildar (Age not specified years) Malappuram7 Post, Pin: 676 509 The Village Officer (Age not specified years) Kalpakancheri & Post, Pin: 676551 The executive Officer (Age not specified years) Ayivanthram Paradevatha Temple, Kalpakancheri, Kalpakancheri Post, Pin: 676 551

Reliefs

Relief Type: Permanent Prohibitory Injunction

Outcome: Not Decided

Description:

Returning the plaint for presentation before the Land Revenue Commissioner in Thiruvananthapuram

Evidence: